The Immersive Collaborative Virtual Environments in Healthcare: A State-of-the-Art Review

Abstract

The healthcare metaverse represents a convergence of virtual reality (VR), augmented reality (AR), mixed reality (MR), and supporting technologies to create immersive digital environments for medical applications. This paper examines the current state and future potential of metaverse technologies in healthcare, analysing market projections, technological infrastructure, clinical applications, and implementation challenges. With market valuations projected to reach between $125.64 billion and $219.1 billion by 2035, the healthcare metaverse shows promise across multiple domains, including telemedicine, surgical planning, medical education, mental health therapy, and rehabilitation. While early research demonstrates positive outcomes in usability and patient engagement, significant challenges remain in technological maturity, data security, regulatory compliance, and maintaining human connection in virtual care. This review synthesises current evidence and identifies key considerations for the ethical and effective implementation of metaverse technologies in healthcare delivery.

1. Introduction

Picture a future where your doctor's office isn't a building but a virtual space you enter from your living room, or in which physical therapy is a form of gentle play. A realm of holography where surgeons rehearse intricate operations before ever cutting into a patient. Today, we're taking a deep dive into this interesting and rapidly changing intersection of the metaverse, these immersive, participatory, virtual reality-based environments, with healthcare. We'll be looking at some actual feasibility, early efficacy signals, some key design considerations and finally the myriad ways these are emerging in health. [1][5][6]

By the metaverse, we're essentially talking about an all-encompassing virtual universe. It's driven by a trio of technologies: virtual reality, augmented reality and mixed reality — or what's known as XR, for extended reality [6][7]. It's kind of like the future internet, a persistent digital layer on which people can move around from virtual space to virtual space using these XR technologies, and feel like they're there. Today, immersive, collaborative virtual environments, or ICVEs, are multi-user spaces in the metaverse, areas where multiple people can be present, engaged, and feel like they are potentially "together" in that virtual space.

2. Background and Historical Context

2.1 Evolution of Virtual Reality Technology

The first VR headset was developed in the 1960s by Ivan Sutherland, and later innovations like graphical user interfaces (GUIs) made it possible for increasingly lifelike and interactive scenes to appear. With Tim Berners-Lee's invention of the World Wide Web in 1989, the foundation was laid for a worldwide structure of digital interactivity, the necessary stepping-stone for the connected spaces we know were soon to be part of the metaverse. [6]

In the late 1990s and early 2000s, persistent virtual worlds began to worm their way into popular culture and life on the Internet. Environments such as MUDs and early MMOGs like Ultima Online and World of Warcraft were early versions of shared worlds where thousands of users were able to play in the same space at the same time. That was in 2003, and Second Life remains a milestone in the development of the metaverse, weaving together social media and a 3D world, and serving as a testing ground for virtual societies and economies. In time, Roblox, Minecraft, and Fortnite built on those principles, creating worlds that the users themselves could tinker with and vast digital communities to share their creations.

2.2 Current Drivers of Adoption

Researchers link this sudden boom of metaverse-related domains to a push-pull phenomenon. The push is coming from continuous, rapid advancements in the XR hardware and software itself. Headsets are getting smaller, lighter, and more powerful, and the pull is coming from clients and healthcare providers themselves. They're actively looking for interventions that are more effective, more accessible and more tailored to individual needs.

The COVID-19 pandemic significantly accelerated this whole trend. It laid bare the limitations of our healthcare systems in no uncertain terms, and at the same time created an overwhelming spike in demand for non-face-to-face services. Telehealth took off, but users wanted more. If you're looking forward, what the metaverse might enable is essentially managing some of these large, large challenges, things like escalating health care costs; infrastructure, that cost; rapidly ageing populations — we're running out of young people to look after so many old people — and shortages of health care personnel [5][6]. The goal is to shift types of care traditionally delivered in crowded hospitals — and now, during a pandemic, particularly risky due to their risk of exposure to the coronavirus — right to people's living rooms.

3. Market Analysis and Projections

The healthcare metaverse market is experiencing unprecedented growth, with multiple research firms projecting exponential expansion over the next decade. According to Grand View Research, the market was valued at $3.36 billion in 2022 and is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 42.6% through 2030. Precedence Research provides even more robust projections, estimating the market at $11.75 billion in 2024, expanding to $125.64 billion by 2034 with a CAGR of 26.74%. Most optimistically, Roots Analysis projects growth from $14.6 billion in 2025 to $219.1 billion by 2035, representing a CAGR of 31.1%. [1][6]

Healthcare metaverse market size projections from multiple research firms, showing exponential growth potential from 2022 to 2035

These projections reflect the increasing adoption of immersive technologies across healthcare institutions globally. The rapid development of augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR), and artificial transformed the healthcare sector, enabling the creation of immersive and realistic healthcare experiences that revolutionise patient care, medical training, and diagnostics. North America currently leads market adoption due to rapid healthcare infrastructure development and integration of AR and VR platforms, while Asia-Pacific is expected to grow fastest during the forecast period.

4. Technological Infrastructure

4.1 Extended Reality (XR) Technologies

The healthcare metaverse is built upon a sophisticated technology stack that integrates multiple cutting-edge innovations. Extended reality, or XR, is the big umbrella term for virtual reality (VR), augmented reality (AR) and mixed reality (MR).[6][7]

• Virtual reality (VR) is where one is completely immersed. Consider headsets like the Oculus Quest 2; they transport you and shut you out of your physical surroundings.
• Augmented reality (AR) enhances your real world. It superimposes digital information, images, and video data onto your view of reality. Apple Vision Pro is a key example where one can see digital stuff floating in their room, like adding a layer.
• Mixed reality (MR) is the true hybrid; it lets you interact with both real and virtual objects in the same space seamlessly. For example, one could be looking at a virtual heart model, but still, reach out and grab your real coffee mug off your real desk, and the system understands both.

4.2 Supporting Technologies

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) are fundamental. They're used to simulate human thinking, enhancing immersive experiences and making virtual services smarter. AI enables domains like natural language processing (NLP) that enhance natural conversation with the system or avatars, like talking to a virtual assistant, but more integrated and much more deeply embedded. Computer Vision (CV) is for identifying objects, tracking facial expressions, and understanding movement accurately.

Network Infrastructure: High-speed networks like 5G and eventually, 6G facilitate super-low latency and high bandwidth for real-time transmission of complex 3D virtual items and services. For domains like remote surgery, there cannot be any ground for lag, especially where milliseconds genuinely matter. Complementing the networks are cloud and edge computing. The Cloud offers scalable storage and processing power for the massive amounts of data generated, while edge computing processes data closer to the source, like on your headset or a local device. [2][5][6]

Blockchain Technology: Think of it like a secure, distributed, digital ledger. Everyone involved can see the entries, but nobody can secretly change them. Once they're recorded, it's immutable. So for healthcare, this means a decentralised, transparent system for secure record keeping. It enhances data security and patient privacy in the metaverse, stops data tampering, and empowers patients to control who accesses their health info. [2][6]

Digital Twins: These are essentially real-time, virtual replicas of physical things or even processes. Clinical applications include Mayo Clinic's patient-specific tumour models that enable oncologists to simulate different treatment options before administration, minimising trial-and-error approaches in cancer therapy. Stanford University has developed digital twin models of the human heart to simulate and study cardiovascular diseases, helping cardiologists assess treatment strategies and improve intervention precision. [1][5][6]

Haptic Technology: This adds the sense of touch, force feedback textures, and vibrations. Devices like the GeoMagic Touch let you feel resistance when simulating drilling a tooth or feel the texture of a virtual object, or maybe even a pulse. It adds this whole layer of realism and immersion. [3][4]

5. Clinical Applications

5.1 Telemedicine and Telehealth

The conversation here is about moving way beyond basic video calls. Think about virtual 3D clinics or offices where patients and clinicians meet as realistic avatars or at least interact in a much richer 3D space. The benefits could be huge — increased patient comfort, perhaps feeling less exposed than on video, secure information transfer within that environment, and importantly, the potential to deliver expert care to really remote areas or even post-disaster zones.

The Emirates Health Services launched a groundbreaking Metaverse-based Virtual Telemedicine Solution using 3D virtual reality technology, enabling patients to access psychiatric consultation services, family health promotion clinics, and customer happiness centres through virtual channels. This platform provides a 3D interactive space that allows customers to engage with healthcare professionals through secure links using standard devices, eliminating the need for specialised equipment. [5][6]

Chosun University Hospital's metaverse digital twin demonstrates the practical implementation of virtual healthcare environments. Built on the ZEP platform to accommodate up to 50,000 simultaneous participants, this mirror world metaverse hospital facilitates face-to-face communication between doctors and patients while providing virtual maps, transportation reservations, and real-time communication with hospital staff. [9][11]

5.2 Surgical Planning and Operations

In surgical planning and operations, you can project medical images like CT scans directly onto a patient's body using AR. It gives surgeons almost X-ray vision during complex procedures. Neurosurgeons at Johns Hopkins, for instance, have used AR headsets for spine surgery, visualising critical anatomy overlaid right onto the patient in real time. Maxillofacial surgery and other virtual implant operations can be done with less room for trial and error. Surgeons can rehearse tricky procedures virtually before they even make an incision on the real patient. [5]

5.3 Pain Management and Distraction Therapy

Creating engaging, beautiful virtual worlds can effectively divert patients' attention from pain during uncomfortable procedures, like VR for kids during vaccinations, VR being used to reduce anxiety during the first trimester procedures or even C-sections. It's a powerful non-drug tool for pain and anxiety. [5][6]

5.4 Diagnostics

In diagnostics, tools like Accuvein use AR to project a map of veins onto the skin, making IV insertions much easier. [6]

5.5 Medical Education and Training

Anatomy Learning can be explored beyond just flat diagrams or even crowded cadaver labs. Imagine students using systems like Hollow Anatomy at Case Western Reserve University. They could walk around and through detailed 3D holographic organs and body systems, and study such structures interactively, as well as remotely.

Surgical training gets a huge boost from realistic simulators. Dental simulators like Moog Simodont VR use haptic feedback so that students can feel the resistance of drilling virtual teeth, so they get the feel for it without risk. Similarly, for complex endoscopic surgery or orthopaedic procedures like placing spinal screws, the implementation of VR simulators allows for safe, repeatable practice of difficult skills. [4]

5.6 Mental Health and Rehabilitation

Mental health therapy, particularly Virtual Reality exposure therapy (VRET), which is used for phobias, anxiety disorders, and PTSD, produces significant improvements in PTSD symptoms with large effect sizes (g = 1.100, p = 0.001) compared to control groups. Programs like Brave Mind for veterans with PTSD, or using VR to safely expose someone to heights if they have acrophobia or spiders or public speaking scenarios, all in a controlled, safe environment with a therapist guiding them precisely, allow for gradual, controlled exposure to anxiety triggers. [5][7]

The Cochrane review of 190 trials involving 7,188 participants found that VR, when used in addition to standard therapy, helps stroke survivors regain arm movement and improves balance while reducing activity limitations. The review noted that VR can offer an inexpensive and engaging way to increase therapy time without requiring constant clinician supervision. [8][9]

Specific applications include the C-Mill VR+ system, which simulates real-life scenarios and everyday challenges in safe environments while utilising force plate technology to assess and train balance and gait. Research indicates this technology improves balance, gait adaptability, gait functionality, dual-tasking, and overall rehabilitation outcomes after stroke. [4]

The World Health Organisation has utilised augmented reality to train COVID-19 responders and mental health experts in virtual reality techniques for treating patients with various mental health conditions, including post-traumatic stress, phobias, anxiety disorders, hallucinations, and delusions. [5]

6. Research Findings and Clinical Evidence

Most of these studies involved healthy young adults and older adults, and generally, the methodological quality was rated pretty highly, especially for the quantitative analyses. There were positive outcomes that were observed, to varying degrees, across several areas. Participants reported high levels of usability on systematic reviews. They reported the systems being relatively easy to use, and a strong sense of presence, feeling like they were really in the virtual place.

There are clear and promising signs, but it's still difficult to make strong, definitive assertions about the overall clinical effectiveness of the metaverse compared to traditional methods, mainly because all the studies we referenced use different approaches, measure different things at different metrics. One consistent piece of user feedback was the need for more training time. People needed a bit longer to get comfortable with the headsets, communication channels and controls, especially if they were new to VR.

Comprehensive radar chart assessment of VR/metaverse healthcare research across multiple dimensions

The research emphasises the benefit of multidisciplinary teams working together and using co-creation, actually designing with the end users, like older adults, to make sure the tech fits their needs by implementing lighter headsets, simpler controllers, clear instructions and tailoring it carefully to achieve behavioural realism.

7. Implementation Challenges and Barriers

7.1 Technological Limitations

While the potential for healthcare in the metaverse to go mainstream is huge, the hurdles are real. First off, technological maturity and stability are ongoing concerns, with the metaverse as a whole concept still being in its early stages. It needs constant updates, integration of multiple complex, often expensive technologies. The hardware itself — the headsets, the haptic gloves are still evolving, getting better, but high-end stuff is pricey, which is a barrier to access for many individuals and healthcare systems.

7.2 Health and Safety Concerns

Cyber sickness is another significant concern where some users experience dizziness, nausea, headaches, and eye strain after using VR. In some studies, participants had to stop sessions early due to it. We need better hardware and software designed to minimise that.

7.3 Data Privacy and Regulatory Compliance

Data privacy and security remain the paramount concern for healthcare applications, considering the vast amounts of incredibly sensitive personal health information, like biometric data from sensors tracking movement. All of this data needs to be stored in compliance with regulations such as HIPAA in the US and GDPR in Europe. Failure to comply isn't just a fine; it's a massive breach of trust, followed by huge reputational damage. Legal issues include determining the relationships between extraterritoriality and local law applications when providing healthcare services across international borders. [6]

7.4 User Experience and Accessibility

We also have the user experience and accessibility challenge for widespread adoption, where all these systems need intuitive designs and simple navigation. It can't require a computer science degree to join your virtual therapy session. We also need adaptive technologies for users with different abilities, compatibility with screen readers, adjustable text sizes, voice control options, gesture controls, and multi-language support for global reach.

There's something researchers call the novelty effect. Just the initial excitement or maybe anxiety of using this cool new technology can influence how people respond in a study, potentially skewing the results about the intervention itself. Researchers try to mitigate this with things like familiarisation sessions before the study starts, or designing studies with multiple sessions over time so that novelty wears off. [7]

7.5 Human Connection and Ethical Considerations

One last challenge, that needs immediate address, is the potential loss of personal touch. Even in an immersive, metaverse environment, remote care can lead to a perceived lack of face-to-face rapport, the unique human connection you get in person, and that bond can be really important for recovery. There's a tension here. Some worry about a technocentric perspective, where we focus too much on the shiny tech itself and forget the user-centred approach.

Multi-dimensional analysis of healthcare metaverse concerns showing varying impacts on patients, healthcare systems, and implementation challenges

8. Future Directions

Virtual reality applications will expand beyond current use cases to include more comprehensive real-life environment simulations, such as shopping in supermarkets or crossing streets, to help patients regain functional abilities for daily activities. This expansion will address current limitations where most VR programs focus on movement training rather than functional ability restoration.

The metaverse enables the creation of comprehensive health profiles through continuous monitoring and predictive analytics, allowing healthcare providers to tailor interventions precisely to individual needs. This personalised approach supports precision medicine initiatives while reducing healthcare costs through early intervention and prevention strategies.

9. Conclusion

As virtual reality, augmented reality, artificial intelligence, and blockchain technologies continue to mature and integrate, the healthcare metaverse will likely become an indispensable component of modern medical practice, fundamentally transforming how we approach health and wellness in the digital age. After we weigh all the incredible potential applications against these significant hurdles, it's still too early to make sweeping, definitive claims about broad clinical effectiveness, mainly because the research methods are still so varied. The initial findings from these immersive, collaborative virtual environments (ICVEs) are undeniably promising.

The key to realising this potential lies in thoughtful, ethical implementation that prioritises patient safety, data security, and equitable access while fostering innovation and collaboration across the global healthcare community. As we move forward into this new era of healthcare delivery, the metaverse offers unprecedented opportunities to improve health outcomes, reduce costs, and enhance the quality of care for patients worldwide.

The metaverse in healthcare isn't just some fleeting tech fad; it is a genuinely developing ecosystem with really profound implications for how healthcare is delivered, how it's learned, and how we experience it globally. We seem to be moving, maybe slowly, but moving towards more personalised, more accessible models of care that could fundamentally reshape how we even think about health and well-being, which leaves us with a final thought to maybe mull over: how might the seamless integration of our virtual selves and our physical selves happen within the metaverse? How might that fundamentally redefine what it even means to be healthy and how we pursue well-being in the decades to come?

References

1. “MetaHealth - How will the Metaverse Change Health Care?” Journal of Metaverse | DergiPark Academik, 31 December 2021, https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/2167692.
2. “Metaverse in Healthcare: Applications, Challenges, and Future Directions.” IEEE Journals & Magazine | IEEE Xplore, 1 July 2023, https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/9956737.
3. “Exploring the Potential of Metaverse Technology in Healthcare: Applications, Challenges, and Future Directions.” IEEE Journals & Magazine | IEEE Xplore, 2023, https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/10153590.
4. “Metaverse for Healthcare: A Survey on Potential Applications, Challenges and Future Directions.” IEEE Journals & Magazine | IEEE Xplore, 2023, https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/10034994.
5. Wang, Yue, et al. “The Application of Metaverse in Healthcare.” Frontiers in Public Health, vol. 12, July 2024, https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2024.1420367.
6. “Healthcare in Metaverse: A Survey on Current Metaverse Applications in Healthcare.” IEEE Journals & Magazine | IEEE Xplore, 2022, https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/9940237.
7. Zarei, Tohid, et al. “‘Being There Together for Health’: A Systematic Review on the Feasibility, Effectiveness and Design Considerations of Immersive Collaborative Virtual Environments in Health Applications.” arXiv.org, 6 Dec. 2024, https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.04760.
8. Brockmeyer, Phillipp, et al. “The Role of Augmented Reality in the Advancement of Minimally Invasive Surgery Procedures: A Scoping Review.” Bioengineering, vol. 10, no. 4, Apr. 2023, p. 501. https://doi.org/10.3390/bioengineering10040501.
9. Kim, Mi Ra, et al. “Introduction and Application of a Metaverse Platform Used in Chosun University Hospital Metaverse.” Clinical and Experimental Emergency Medicine, vol. 11, no. 1, Jan. 2024, pp. 106–14. https://doi.org/10.15441/ceem.23.086.
10. Mistry, Dipal, et al. “The Present and Future of Virtual Reality in Medical Education: A Narrative Review.” Cureus, Dec. 2023, https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.51124.
11. Santra, Ratul. “Blockchain-Based Healthcare Metaverse Development.” IdeaUsher, 20 Feb. 2025, https://ideausher.com/blog/blockchain-healthcare-metaverse.